I know this is an old topic. I believed in justification from eternity for a while, but I stopped believing because I couldn't find any record of it in the earliest of church writers. I see that the scripture could be interpreted both ways, either for or against eternal justification, and since I can't find this belief before the 16th-17th century, I assume it is more probably a later invention of men. Honestly, nothing brought me more joy than believing in J from E. So, if anyone can provide me reason to believe it despite what I wrote above, I would be absolutely thrilled.