Bootstrap
Brandan Kraft

More Tell-Tale Signs That You're Dealing with a Neo-Gnostic

Brandan Kraft 4 min read
196 Articles 23 Sermons
0 Comments
Brandan Kraft
Brandan Kraft 4 min read
196 articles 23 sermons

Brandan Kraft identifies characteristic behaviors and doctrinal errors of neo-Gnosticism in contemporary Christianity, arguing that this movement prioritizes intellectual knowledge and doctrinal precision over relational faith and practical holiness. Neo-Gnostics, according to Kraft, demand exact Gospel articulation for salvation (rejecting simple faith), deny eternal justification, emphasize error-detection over edification, isolate from church fellowship, and display pride and combativeness contrary to Titus 3:2 and 1 Timothy 6:4. The movement fundamentally confuses cognitive assent with saving faith, treating the Gospel as a formula rather than a transformative relationship with Christ that produces the fruit of the Spirit (Galatians 5:22-23).

Outline

I. Introduction to Neo-Gnosticism
  • Definition of Neo-Gnosticism
  • Link to contemporary Christian discourse
  • Quote from John Newton regarding the spirit of criticism
II. Characteristics of Neo-Gnostic Believers
  • Social Media Practices
  • Celebration of controversial figures (e.g., Martin Luther)
  • Focus on critical posts over edifying content
  • Isolation from the Church
  • Avoidance of church services and conferences
  • Lack of fellowship with other believers
  • Production of Content
  • Creation of attack videos on heretics
  • Constant criticism without promoting positive Gospel messages
III. Attitude Toward the Gospel
  • View of Salvation
  • Treatment of the Gospel as a formula
  • Boasting in knowledge over love and humility
  • Critique of Traditional Doctrine
  • Constantly criticizing historical theologians
  • Refusal to recognize growth in believers’ understanding over time
IV. Theological Errors and Attitudes
  • Misunderstanding of Justification
  • Denial of eternal justification
  • Lack of understanding of righteousness imputation
  • Binary Thinking
  • Simplistically categorizing individuals as saved or lost
  • Association with Arminian theology
  • Reaction to Error
  • Insistence on logical implications of beliefs
  • Confrontational attitude towards other believers
V. Lack of Christian Virtues
  • Absence of Gentleness and Kindness
  • Failure to assemble with the saints (Hebrews 10:25)
  • Combative attitude as a normative behavior
VI. Conclusion
  • Summary of Neo-Gnostic implications for the church
  • Call to return to grace, love, and humility in theology

Key Quotes

“They literally will wear their religion on their sleeve.”

“Salvation is not a formula.”

“True assent is downplayed or outright ignored.”

“Constantly posting about the self-righteousness of others while being acutely unaware of their own self-righteousness.”

“Acquisition and apprehension of knowledge is incorrectly considered to be saving faith.”

Scripture References

  • Matthew 15:24: Context of Christ's mission to the lost sheep of Israel.
  • Hebrews 10:25: Encouragement not to neglect meeting together, reflecting the importance of fellowship.
  • 1 Timothy 6:4: Addressing the combative attitude that leads to unhealthy disputes.
  • Galatians 5:22-23: Discussing the fruit of the Spirit, contrasting with the neo-gnostic's view on joy and love.

Doctrinal Themes

  • Importance of communal worship and fellowship.
  • Recognition of justification by faith alone, apart from works.
  • Emphasis on grace and humility over knowledge and criticism.
  • The need for positive edification in the church body.
  • The danger of binary thinking in spiritual categorization.
What does the Bible say about the Neo-Gnostic approach to faith?

The Bible warns against false teachings and encourages unity and fellowship among believers.

The Bible cautions against philosophies that deny essential truths of faith, emphasizing the importance of sound doctrine and community among believers. Paul’s letters often address the dangers of divisive teachings and encourage the church to remain grounded in the Gospel (Galatians 1:6-9). Neo-Gnosticism, defined by a focus on secret knowledge and a disdain for traditional teachings, diverges from the biblical emphasis on grace and community. Hebrews 10:25 specifically urges believers not to neglect gathering together, highlighting the importance of fellowship in faith.

Galatians 1:6-9, Hebrews 10:25

Why is sound doctrine important for Christians?

Sound doctrine is vital because it shapes our understanding of God and guides our faith in truth.

Sound doctrine serves as the foundation for the Christian faith, ensuring that believers are anchored in truth rather than the shifting ideas of contemporary culture. The New Testament frequently highlights the need for accurate teaching, warning against those who distort the Gospel for personal gain (1 Timothy 6:3-5). By grounding themselves in sound doctrine, Christians can discern error, grow in grace, and maintain unity within the Body of Christ. Moreover, sound preaching nurtures spiritual growth and fosters a deeper relationship with God, enabling believers to thrive amid challenges.

1 Timothy 6:3-5

How do we know justification from eternity is true?

Justification from eternity is supported by Scripture, affirming God's sovereign grace in salvation.

The concept of justification from eternity is rooted in the sovereign will of God and His eternal plan for redemption. Scriptures such as Ephesians 1:4-5 reveal that believers were chosen before the foundation of the world, indicating that God's declaration of righteousness precedes individual faith. This doctrine underscores the total dependence on God's grace rather than human effort. Furthermore, Romans 8:30 emphasizes that those whom God predestines are also called, justified, and glorified, showcasing an unbreakable chain governed by divine grace. Affirming justification from eternity encourages believers to embrace their security in Christ, detached from fluctuating performances.

Ephesians 1:4-5, Romans 8:30

What are the characteristics of a Neo-Gnostic believer?

Neo-Gnostic believers often focus on knowledge over faith, lack community, and criticize others instead of edifying.

A Neo-Gnostic believer tends to prioritize a rigorous intellectual understanding of the faith, often leading to a proud disposition rather than a humble pursuit of truth. This mindset manifests in a fixation on critiquing others and a lack of compassion and community engagement. Such individuals frequently post about perceived errors in teachings and engage in combative discussions, missing the vital aspects of love and unity that the Gospel promotes (1 Timothy 6:4). Additionally, their reluctance to gather with other believers (Hebrews 10:25) reflects a disconnect from the communal nature of faith, emphasizing personal knowledge rather than collective growth in grace and truth.

1 Timothy 6:4, Hebrews 10:25

"'[He] frequently finds more bones than meat, and is seasoned with much of an angry and self-important spirit."  - John Newton

    Here are some more tell-tale signs you're dealing with a neo-gnostic...

  1. Facebook posts like, "Martin Luther promoted a false gospel," and nothing else being added to it is seen as edifying.  Celebration of such posts are part and parcel of staying within good graces of the neo-gnostic circles.
  2. Won't attend church services, or conferences.  Won't reach out to nearby believers for fellowship.  They lock themselves inside all day and every day, sitting on their computers making videos or posting on forums or social media just attacking others.
  3. Postive Gospel preaching is not seen as edifying, but something to critique.
  4. Attacking old teachers of the past, refusing to look for good in anything they may have taught, and refusing to even consider that maybe some people grow in grace and knowledge of the truth over the course of a lifetime.  An errant doctrine taught by a younger, less wise and less illuminated teacher will forever condemn that person in the eyes of the neo-gnostic.  Martin Luther wasn't ALWAYS an unbeliever.
  5. Posting nothing on facebook except your favorite quotes by one or two or three particular people.  If you're a leader in the neo-gnostic community, most of the quotes are your own or for others to widely disseminate on facebook on a daily and semi-hourly basis.
  6. Some neo-gnostics are good at creating videos attacking their heretic of the day.  The majority of their videos are those attacking others.
  7. Constantly posting about the self-righteousness of others while being accutely unaware of their own self-righteousness and their proud, haughty, and angry spirit on display.
  8. Treating the Gospel like it's a formula.  Salvation is not a formula!
  9. Boasting in knowledge.
  10. A lack of love.
  11. A lack of humility.
  12. Most material produced is about pointing out error in others.  Positive Gospel preaching without antithesis is nowhere to be found. 
  13. A self-promoter.

    Here is my original list:   

  14. An insistence on the exact articulation of the Gospel in all of its fullness and having the ability to recognize all of its implications is necessary in order to be "saved."  A simple child-like faith is not permissable in their scheme.  Toplady's words, "Nothing in my hand I bring, simply to Thy cross I cling" would need to be amended signficantly!
  15. Constantly referring to individuals as either "saved" or "lost".  In the gnostic scheme, those are only the two possible states of an indivual.  If you're not "saved", you're "lost."  Ironically, they are still very arminian in their thinking, not recognizing that being "lost" is actually a good thing as Christ came for the lost sheep of Israel (Mat. 15:24).
  16. An emphatic denial of justification from eternity.  They would say God does not impute righteousness to an individual until they have true faith.  They of course would deny that this righteousness is based on this faith.  Some have even gone so far as to insist that belief in any eternal aspect of justification proves one is "lost." - See my article the Four Aspects of Justification.
  17. A belief in common wrath.  Common wrath is the teaching that all people are under the wrath of God, even the elect.  God's wrath stops abiding on the elect person when they believe and righteousness is imputed.
  18. An insistence that the logical implications of an error are the actual propositions one believes.  This insistence applies even to one's associations with people.  If one defends or even "speaks peace" to one who is in error, then one has indeed adopted their error as their own and hence proven to all their "lost" status. (See my article on Tolerant Calvinists.)
  19. A lack of gentleness and kindness (Titus 3:2).
  20. A lack of desire to be assembled with the saints in any capacity (Heb. 10:25).
  21. A confrontational and combative attitude (1 Timothy 6:4).
  22. Focusing all of their efforts on pointing out error instead of building up and edifying others.
  23. Glorying in their ability to point out error with internet memes, signs, and attire.  They literally will wear their religion on their sleeve.
  24. Some will even argue against love and joy, insisting that these things are not necessary consequences to belief in the Gospel (Gal. 5:22-23).  They will even mock those who insist that Christ produces fruit in His people as "navel gazers."
  25. Acquisition and apprehension of knowledge is incorrectly considered to be saving faith.  True assent is downplayed or outright ignored.  Cognition alone is the predicate of entrance into the kingdom of God.
  26. An insistence on concurrence with all their logical leaps is necessary to be considered as one of their own.

Comments

0 / 2000 characters
Comments are moderated before appearing.

Be the first to comment!

3
Joshua

Joshua

Shall we play a game? Ask me about articles, sermons, or theology from our library. I can also help you navigate the site.