Why do some reject the idea of universal atonement?

The concept of universal atonement is rejected on the grounds that Scripture reveals a definitive atonement accomplished by Christ specifically for His elect. In Hebrews 9:28, we learn that Christ was offered to bear the sins of many, directly implying that not every individual benefits from His sacrifice. The Helvetic Consensus further echoes this sentiment by affirming that the Gospel's offer of salvation is not universal in an absolute sense. Instead, the atonement is particular, and God’s sovereign grace determines who will be redeemed. This distinction maintains the integrity of Christ's work, aligning with the biblical evidence that emphasizes God’s chosen people throughout Scripture.