Bootstrap
Mike Krall

Is Soul Winning the Measure of Spirituality?

Mike Krall 7 min read
11 Articles
0 Comments
Mike Krall
Mike Krall 7 min read
11 articles

Krall argues that modern evangelicalism wrongly measures spiritual maturity by soul-winning statistics and aggressive evangelistic methods rather than by personal holiness and conformity to Christ's image. Drawing on passages like 1 Peter 3:15 and 1 Thessalonians 4:11-12, he contends that believers should prioritize living godly, blameless lives before unbelievers while remaining ready to share the gospel opportunistically, rather than employing unbiblical marketing techniques or coercing financial support for evangelistic programs. He emphasizes that God's sovereignty in salvation means the gospel spreads through God's providence, not human-engineered methods, and that binding believers' consciences to particular evangelistic practices contradicts Scripture's teaching on Christian liberty and voluntary giving (2 Corinthians 9:7).

What does the Bible say about soul winning and spirituality?

The Bible emphasizes that true spirituality is about conforming to Christ's image, not just the number of souls won.

The Bible teaches that spirituality is not measured merely by the act of soul winning but by our growth in Christlikeness. Verses such as 1 Peter 3:15 highlight the importance of being prepared to share the hope within us, pointing to the need for a life reflective of Christ's character as foundational to our witness. A focus solely on numbers can distract from true spiritual growth and hinder deeper communion with God.

Furthermore, the Great Commission as given in Matthew 10:9 points to the Lord's direction for His disciples to preach the gospel without being overly concerned with material means. The emphasis should be on the heart's condition and our obedience to God instead of measuring ourselves against a checklist of achievements in evangelism. Thus, the measure of spirituality in a believer or church should reflect a deeper relationship with God and His purposes rather than just visible outcomes of soul winning.
How do we know the Great Commission is still applicable today?

The Great Commission serves as a directive for believers, encouraging gospel proclamation as God's chosen method for salvation.

While some debate the current application of the Great Commission, it remains a critical directive rooted in Scripture. Jesus' commandment to His apostles to preach the gospel remains relevant as it aligns with God's sovereign plan for salvation. Matthew 28:19-20 records the commission to make disciples of all nations, which emphasizes preaching the gospel as central to Christ's mission.

However, it is vital to recognize that fulfilling the Great Commission does not equate to a mechanical approach of tallying conversions. Instead, engaging in evangelism should stem from a heart transformed by grace and guided by the Holy Spirit, marking our efforts to share the gospel as manifestations of our love for Christ. Believers are called to be vessels for God's grace, trusting Him to draw the elect to Himself in His timing and way.
Why is living a godly life important for Christians?

Living a godly life reflects Christ's character, which is essential for effective witness and true spirituality.

A godly life is essential for Christians as it serves as a testament to the transformative power of the gospel. In 1 Thessalonians 4:11-12, Christians are called to live quietly, work diligently, and walk honestly before others. This lifestyle not only reflects our identity as children of God but also opens opportunities to engage others regarding the hope that we possess in Christ.

Moreover, the inward transformation that accompanies salvation should manifest outwardly in how we live. The importance of measuring spiritual growth not by numbers but by our conformity to Christ's image cannot be overstated. Such living allows believers to be effective witnesses without coercion, emphasizing the beauty of the gospel and the compelling nature of a life lived in humble obedience to God, thereby attracting others to Him.
How should Christians approach evangelism according to the Bible?

Christians should approach evangelism with the intent to share the gospel out of love, not obligation or fear of judgment.

Evangelism should be approached as an overflow of gratitude for God's grace and a desire to point others to the Savior rather than a checklist of duties. The Gospel, fundamentally good news, brings hope, and its proclamation should reflect our love for Christ and His work in us (1 Peter 3:15).

Christians are not called to use coercive methods or fleshly strategies, as these undermine the truth of the gospel. Instead, we must rely on the Holy Spirit's guidance and timing, sharing the message of grace with integrity and humility. This approach aligns with our understanding of God's sovereignty in salvation, recognizing that it is ultimately God who draws individuals to Himself. In all discussions of evangelism, we must remain mindful to not bind the consciences of fellow believers regarding methods or results, but encourage genuine expressions of faith that flow from knowing and loving Christ.

     About 12 or so years ago we paid visit on a specific Lord's day to a near by Arminian fundamentalist church. The theme that had been propagated was the 90% tithe week. It seemed that the following Lord's day was going to be the 90% tithe week as opposed to their usual legalistic 10% tithe. This time they wanted to prove how much God was going to honor the giving of these tithitarians. 

     Although memory does not serve me too well to recall whether or not missions was the theme with this effort of 90%, in most cases that is usually the conscience binding argument for bringing in an Old Testament practice into the New Testament. It certainly was not found in the New Testament for we are told that giving should be "not grudgingly or out of necessity" but as one has "purposed in his heart" 2Cor 9:7.

     Now although our theme is soul winning and spirituality, or godliness, we believed it necessary to bring in the subject of giving because it enters into much of modern day evangelism. We recently received a correspondence by a professed brother who seemed to find it necessary to take us to task for our stance on the great commission and its fulfillment by the apostles. 

      One of the things that has led to the taking up of the subject of the fulfillment of the great commission was not because we did not think it was necessary for a church to preach the gospel to those outside of Christ. We made it clear that God's servant should proclaim the gospel of God's free and sovereign grace whenever and wherever God gives opportunity. Nonetheless some deem it necessary to slander us as being those who have no compassion for souls. 

     That brings us to the theme of this paper. What is the measure of the spirituality of a church and/or an individual believer? Is one's spiritual state of growth to be seen in how many tracts he hands out or how many co-workers he has dragged into a discussion about the gospel? 

     To many that is the case. If one scans a search engine on the internet and types in "great commission" he will see the many that are more concerned with how many souls they have won than how much they have come to love the precious Savior and how much they are being conformed to the His image. You will even find instruction how you can do your part in fulfilling the great commission. I suggest if you follow their advice to hold onto your wallet. 

     It is not our intent to chastise or criticize any servant of Christ who desires to preach the gospel to a certain segment of the world because they believe the Lord has called them to that task. We most certainly do not know the mind of the Lord in his dealings with his children. But we do know that any mission the Lord sends one of his chosen to perform he most certainly will provide the means for such a task. But to bind the consciences of His children and plead for funds or the task will not get done is foreign to Scripture. When the disciples were first commissioned they were told to "provide no gold nor silver nor brass in your purses" Matt. 10:9. This was the command of our Lord in the initial commission to his apostles and was carried into the great commission. But those that believe the great commission is in force today have forgotten this fact. The apostles followed these instructions as they went for to "preach the gospel to every creature." 

     Since it is not our intention to offend those on such a mission what is our purpose in this paper? We believe that the reason for such a vehement approach to evangelism goes far beyond the pale of merely desiring to see many come to a saving knowledge of the Savior. All true children of the King rejoice to see his kingdom grow. But to many it is the measure of ones state of spiritual growth. 

     One of the reasons we believe is because it is far easier to be on the offensive in our efforts to reach the lost than to live a godly life above reproach and do as Peter instructed us "sanctify the Lord God in your hearts: and be ready always to give an answer of every man that asketh you of the reason of the hope that is in you with meekness and fear" 1Pet 3:15. 

     Now if it was standard practice to be on the offensive instead of the defensive there would be little instruction needed by Peter here. After all those around you would not have to ask you of the reason of this hope because you would have let them know way before they ever had any desire to know. That is modern day evangelism and it is pitiful. Somehow if one has not spoken to every one they know about the gospel and gave them all a tract whether or not they showed the slightest bit of interest, that person is considered a second class Christian. 

     Then of course we cannot forget all of the methods that must be employed. We have to have our arsenal of Christian contemporary music to substitute for the music these people listen to. Somehow that is suppose to spark the interest of dead sinners. I can expect the free will Arminians and Pelegians with their false gospel to do this but when those that have embraced the biblical doctrine of God's free and sovereign grace that says men are dead in sin and need life to believe it then becomes more pitiful when they succumb to the language of Ashdod. 

     Despite all the efforts of the free willer Arminians and the free offer sovereign gracers, not one more will be saved by these nonbiblical methods. God is determined to bring his children into a saving knowledge of Christ and he most certainly has chosen to do this via the preaching of the gospel. But if we think that conjuring up flesh pleasing worldly methods in the name of the great commission, at the cost of living a life as instructed by Paul to "study to be quiet, and to do your own business, and to work with your own hands, as we commanded you; That ye may walk honestly toward them that are without, and that ye may have lack of nothing" (1Thes 4:11-12) we are most certainly mistaken. 

     We seemed to have forgotten the exhortations given us about on the one hand not "casting pearls before swine" and on the other being a shining light before "a crooked and perverse generation." It is far more flesh pleasing to be a modern day soul winner than to live a quiet blameless life before the unbelieving world as instructed in the passages we have quoted. 

     So what do we say to these things? We believe that no true child of the King needs to be coerced into bearing witness to the gospel of God's free grace. But to make that the measure of one's growth in grace most certainly will cause one to put more focus on "soul winning" than feeding his own soul and being watchful against the snares of the enemy. Do we believe in preaching to sinners? Yes for we do not know of any other kind but sinners. But the gospel is sheep food not goat food and it is good news not good advice. So we will take every opportunity the Lord finds favor to give us to bear witness to the truth. But in the mean time we will not bind the consciences of others as to the use of methods that are both unbiblical and laced with carnality and pride. Cast not your pearls before swine but instead "be ready always to give an answer."

Comments

0 / 2000 characters
Comments are moderated before appearing.

Be the first to comment!

Joshua

Joshua

Shall we play a game? Ask me about articles, sermons, or theology from our library. I can also help you navigate the site.