In Thomas Manton's commentary on James 1:11, the author addresses the transitory nature of wealth and worldly pursuits, comparing them to fading flowers. Manton argues that both rich and poor may experience the ephemeral quality of worldly comforts, emphasizing that the rich man will ultimately fade away despite his toil. He draws on various Scripture references, such as Job 21:7-10, to illustrate that prosperity does not guarantee enduring blessings, and he reminds readers of the consequences of idolatry and misplaced trust in wealth, as seen in 1 Timothy 6:17 and James 5:3. The practical implications of Manton's teaching encourage believers to detach their hearts from temporary comforts and to recognize God's providence as essential for genuinely prosperous labor, lest they fall into despair when earthly pursuits dissipate.
Key Quotes
“The flower fades by itself but especially when it is scorched by the burning east wind.”
“While the rich goes about his business, all his endeavors will be fruitless if God's hand is against us.”
“You earn wages only to put them in a purse with holes in it.”
“Shall an evil desire have more power over them than God's love does over me?”
What does the Bible say about the transience of earthly wealth?
The Bible highlights that earthly wealth is temporary and can fade away, much like flowers scorched by the sun (James 1:11).
The apostle James specifically points out that while the rich man engages earnestly in his pursuits, like a flower, he is subject to the inevitable decay that follows. Just as flowers appear glorious in their season but die when the sun rises, so too will the comforts of the rich dissipate. This teaches us to remain detached from worldly possessions and cultivate a trust in God's enduring provision rather than in the vanity of our wealth.
James 1:11, Job 21:7-10, 1 Timothy 6:17
How do we know that trusting in riches is unwise according to Scripture?
Scripture cautions that trusting in riches is destructive, as demonstrated in James 5:3, which warns against hoarding wealth and making it an idol.
Moreover, 1 Timothy 6:17 reinforces this warning, urging the rich not to be arrogant or to put their hope in wealth, which is uncertain. Instead, believers are encouraged to place their faith in God who richly provides for their needs. This perspective underscores that true security comes not from material wealth but from a relationship with God, who remains steadfast amid the temporal nature of worldly riches.
James 5:3, 1 Timothy 6:17
Why is it important for Christians to understand the concept of providence?
Understanding providence is crucial for Christians as it helps them recognize God's sovereign hand in their lives, ensuring all works for their good (Romans 8:28).
Furthermore, acknowledging God's providence leads believers to understand that their efforts are in vain if not aligned with divine will. As stated in Psalm 127:1, 'Unless the Lord builds the house, those who build it labor in vain.' This perspective shifts the focus from self-sufficiency to reliance on God, fostering a spirit of humility and dependence that is crucial in the Christian faith.
Romans 8:28, Psalm 127:1
Forthesunriseswithscorchingheatandwitherstheplant;itsblossomfallsanditsbeautyis destroyed. In the same way, the rich man will fade away even while he goes about his business.
James continues the simile and at the end of the verse applies it. Nothing needs explaining except the latter clause.
Willfade. That is, may fade, for the passage is not absolutely definite about what always will be, but simply declares what may be; and therefore the future tense is used. We see many times that “the wicked live on, growing old” (see Job 21:7-10). So the apostle does not say what always happens but what may be, what usually happens, and what will eventually happen.
Therichman. This may either be taken generally to mean the rich, whether godly or ungodly, or more specifically for the ungodly person who trusts in riches.
Fade away. The word is used of plants when they lose their beauty.
Whilehegoesabouthisbusiness. Some read, as do Erasmus and Gagneus, “with his abundance,” which Calvin also approves as fitting the context: “So shall the rich and all his abundance fade away.” However, we follow the general and more commonly received meaning, “in his ways or journeys.” The word is emphatic and refers to that earnest industry by which people travel on sea and land, running here and there in pursuit of wealth; and yet, when all is done, it fades like the flower of the field.
Notes on Verse 11
Note1. From the continuation of the simile, note that the vanity of flowers should make us think about the vanity of our own comforts. We delight in pictures, for through them the soul, with the help of the imagination, has a double view of the object—a picture of it, and then the thing itself. This was God’s former way of teaching his people through types; he still teaches us through similes taken from ordinary objects. When we think of them, spiritual thoughts may awake; every ordinary object is, as it were, hallowed and consecrated for a heavenly purpose. So let this be your field or garden meditation: when you see the plants full of splendor, remember that all this disappears in an instant when the sun rises. The text says, thesunriseswithscorchingheat. The Greek word used here is usually translated “scorching wind,” which in the hot eastern countries came with the rising sun; see Jonah 4:8. It was a hot, piercing wind that blasted all things and was the usual symbol of God’s judgments. When you walk in a garden or field to meditate, as Isaac did (see Genesis 24:63), think, “What a picture! But alas, these things last only for a season; they would fade away of their own accord, but more, the east wind will soon dry them up.” In the same way, all worldly comforts are like spring flowers, good in their season but perishable.
Note 2. Our comforts fade away, especially when the hand of providence is stretched out against them. The flower fades by itself, but especially when it is scorched by the burning east wind. Our hearts should be detached from outward things. Do not make providence your enemy, for your comforts will perish more quickly. You cannot then expect a comfortable warmth from God but a burning heat. There are three sins in which you make providence your enemy:
(1) When you use your comforts to serve your lusts. Where there is pride and wantonness, you may expect a burning; certainly your flowers will be scorched and dried up. Salvian has said, “God will rain hell out of heaven rather than not visit for such sins.”
(2) When you trust in those comforts. God can brook no rivals. If you make idols of creatures, God will destroy them. When you trust in your wealth, as if it will supply your family’s needs, God will show that riches are useless when they are preferred to the living God (see 1 Timothy 6:17).
(3) When you obtain comforts in wrong ways. James 5:3 says, Yourgoldandsilverare corroded.Theircorrosionwilltestifyagainstyouandeatyourfleshlikefire. The fire of God’s wrath falls on your family.
Note3. Whilehegoesabouthisbusiness. Worldly men pursue wealth with great care and industry. The rich have several ways of accomplishing their ends. What pains people take for things that perish! Observe their incessant care, earnest labor, and unwearied industry, and see how appropriate this would be for heavenly treasure! Secondly, observe such persons’ work and care, and ask, shall an evil desire have more power over them than God’s love does over me? I have loftier motives and a more certain reward (Proverbs 11:18); they are more earnest for an earthly purchase and to heap up treasure for themselves than I am to enrich my soul with spiritual and heavenly excellences. Pambus, in ecclesiastical history, wept when he saw a harlot dressed with great care and expense, partly because she took such pains for her own undoing, and partly because he had not been so keen to please God as she had been to please a wanton lover. We should be ashamed that we do so little for Christ while others do so much for wealth.
Note4. Whilehegoesabouthisbusiness. All our endeavors will be fruitless if God’s hand is against us. As the flower is to burning heat, so is the rich man in his ways; that is, despite all his industry and care, God may quickly destroy him. “You earn wages, only to put them in a purse with holes in it” (Haggai 1:6); that is, they did not benefit from their gains. Peter “worked hard all night” but caught nothing until he took Christ into the boat (see Luke 5:5). So you will catch nothing until you take God along with you (see Psalm 127:1). So, acknowledge providence in order to come under its blessing. Labor withoutGod cannot prosper; laboragainstGod, and against his will, will end in disaster.
Comments
Your comment has been submitted and is awaiting moderation. Once approved, it will appear on this page.
Be the first to comment!