Sin in church leaders should be addressed through confrontation, accountability, and a goal of restoration.
When a church leader is found in sin, the approach must be one of grace, seeking restoration rather than punishment. According to Matthew 18:15-17, the first step is to privately confront the individual. If there is no repentance, it should be taken to others who can assist in the process. For persistent sin among leaders, Paul instructs in 1 Timothy 5:20 that they are to be confronted publicly as a means to instill a healthy fear of accountability among others. The goal of such discipline is not condemnation but rather restoration, as God desires all His children to come to repentance and be reconciled to Him. This reflects the greater theological truth that discipline within the church is rooted in God's love and grace, aimed at guiding individuals back to holiness and right relationship with Him.
Scripture References:
Matthew 18:15-17, 1 Timothy 5:20
Commentary