In the sermon titled "Does James Contradict Paul?" Mikal Smith addresses the theological tension between the epistles of James and Paul regarding justification and the role of works in the life of faith. He argues that while Paul emphasizes justification by faith alone, James presents works as a necessary expression of genuine faith. This relationship is illuminated through a careful analysis of Scripture, particularly referencing James 2:14-26 and Romans 3:20, 5:1-2, which demonstrate how faith without works is dead and how justification is fundamentally rooted in Christ's faithfulness rather than human effort. Smith highlights the dual perspectives of justification: legal before God as taught by Paul, and evidential before men as elucidated by James, underlining the importance of recognizing both dimensions without seeing them as contradictory. Ultimately, he emphasizes that true faith, as a gift of God, will naturally produce works as an outworking of grace, thereby reinforcing the doctrine of sola fide.
Key Quotes
“The problem is our understanding. Our problem is the vantage point in which we look at this.”
“James is saying something from a different vantage point, which is actually saying what Paul is saying in a different way.”
“If you are trying to seek justification by your works, it's going to be not grace that you receive, it's going to be wages.”
“Faith is the evidence of things not seen, not works. But when faith is there... it produces the fruits of the Spirit.”
The Bible teaches that faith without works is dead, meaning true faith is evidenced by good works.
In James 2, the Apostle James argues that a faith that does not produce works is ineffective and cannot save. He uses the example of Abraham, stating that his faith was made perfect through his works when he obeyed God and offered Isaac as a sacrifice (James 2:21-22). This illustrates that while justification before God is through faith alone, as Paul teaches, true faith naturally results in good works as evidence of that faith. Therefore, James emphasizes that our treatment of others, particularly our brethren, reflects the reality of our faith in action.
James 2:14-26
Justification by faith is confirmed through scriptural teachings from both Paul and James which complement rather than contradict each other.
Scripture states unequivocally in Romans 3:28 that a man is justified by faith apart from the works of the law. This doctrine is foundational and reaffirms that our legal standing before God is based solely on Christ's righteousness, not our works. However, James presents a different perspective by highlighting that our justification before men, evidenced through works, confirms our faith (James 2:18). Both Paul and James emphasize distinct aspects of salvation, showing that genuine faith in Christ inevitably leads to a life marked by good works as God works within us to will and to act according to His good purpose (Philippians 2:13). Therefore, we conclude that the harmony of these writings supports the truth of justification by faith alone.
Romans 3:28, James 2:18, Philippians 2:13
Understanding the relationship between faith and works helps Christians live out their faith authentically and avoids legalism.
It is vital for Christians to grasp the relationship between faith and works to prevent the misunderstanding that salvation can be earned through human effort. James clarifies that while works do not justify us before God, they serve as a demonstration of the inward transformation wrought by faith. As children of God, we are called to exhibit our faith through actions that reflect the love and grace we have received, especially in our treatment of one another (James 2:15-16). This understanding cultivates a community of grace where each member recognizes that their good works are not a means to boast, but a natural outflow of God’s spirit working through them, leading to a life of service and love towards others.
James 2:15-16, Ephesians 2:8-10
Comments
Your comment has been submitted and is awaiting moderation. Once approved, it will appear on this page.
Be the first to comment!