Bootstrap
Brandan Kraft

Why Are Believers so Cruel to Each Other Online?

Brandan Kraft 4 min read
196 Articles 22 Sermons
0 Comments
Brandan Kraft
Brandan Kraft 4 min read
196 articles 22 sermons

Brandan Kraft examines the prevalence of Christian online cruelty, arguing that the internet has not made believers more cruel but rather revealed their sinful hearts through the ease of anonymous criticism without consequence. He contends that while digital publishing has democratized the gospel's reach, it has also enabled believers to attack one another freely through polemics and character assassination, often for the purpose of gaining followers rather than edifying the body of Christ. Kraft appeals to John 13:34-35, emphasizing that Christians will be known by their love for one another rather than their rhetorical victories, and calls believers to examine their motives before engaging in public criticism—asking whether their words edify, whether attacking concepts rather than persons would be more effective, and ultimately remembering that "Christ and Him crucified" should be their focus.

What does the Bible say about loving one another?

The Bible teaches that we are to love one another as Christ has loved us (John 13:34-35).

The scriptures emphasize love as the hallmark of Christian identity. In John 13:34-35, Jesus commands His followers to love one another, stating that this love is the distinguishing mark of His disciples. Rather than engaging in attacks or debates that tear others down, believers are called to uplift one another, reflecting the grace and mercy they have received. The exhortation to love includes a call to consider the motivations behind our words and actions, ensuring they align with the truth of God's Word and the character of Christ.

John 13:34-35

Why is it harmful for Christians to attack each other online?

Attacking fellow believers can lead to division and harm instead of edification (Romans 14:19).

Online attacks among Christians often stem from a lack of accountability and can reveal the stony hearts that dwell within. Such behavior not only harms the individual being attacked but also affects the wider community of believers by fostering division and animosity. Romans 14:19 encourages believers to pursue peace and mutual edification rather than engaging in destructive speech. When Christians attack one another, they detract from the message of the Gospel and fail to reflect Christ’s love and reconciliation, which should be at the heart of our interactions.

Romans 14:19

How do we know the doctrine of love is true?

The doctrine of love is grounded in Christ's sacrificial love for us (1 John 4:19).

The truth of the doctrine of love is anchored in the example of Christ, who demonstrated perfect love through His sacrificial death. 1 John 4:19 states, 'We love because He first loved us,' affirming that our capacity to love originates from the transformative experience of knowing Christ's love. This foundational truth compels believers not only to love God but also to extend that love to one another. As we reflect on Christ's love and His command to love others, we can discern the authenticity of this doctrine and its paramount importance in our lives.

1 John 4:19

Why should Christians avoid polemical speech?

Polemical speech can damage relationships and contradict the spirit of Christian love.

While defending the faith is a necessary endeavor, engaging in polemical speech can often lead to harm rather than constructive dialogue. Such speech frequently prioritizes winning arguments over fostering genuine understanding and can alienate fellow believers. It is essential for Christians to weigh their words carefully and to ask themselves whether their speech reflects the love of Christ. Engaging in respectful discourse that adheres to the teachings of Scripture can promote unity and growth within the Body of Christ, rather than division and strife.

    Before the Internet existed, believers would skewer each other face to face, and often by the pulpit and by the stroke of the pen.   But it's not as frequently as I find it today!  The cruelty of believers toward each other online is rampant!  And I'm guilty as well - very few have unclean lips in this regard.  Now today, through the use of the internet, one can attack almost seemingly without repercussion.  If I wanted to write against the current president on my social media page, there would hardly be an outrage.  Oh for sure, someone might get their feathers ruffled, but I could put my clean church clothes on and stroll on down to the evening service tonight and not really suffer for my attack.  And I suppose that is one of the reasons why it is so easy to attack other believers.  We can do it in relative comfort, and for many of us, there are no real apparent consequences for speaking out against someone, and calling them a heretic, or using some form of polemical speech against them.  We stare at our phone and computer screens in relative anonymity.

    And the internet has been such a blessing to folks like me.  Prior to the internet, if one wanted to publish something, it usually cost something.  It was costly to put out a Gospel tract, a radio ministry, or publish a book.  And it still costs money to keep the lights on in a church building somewhere so some preacher can stand before an assembly and preach the Gospel.  But now, it's pretty cheap to publish something.  This article for example, it may be read by hundreds, maybe even thousands of people over time.  It won't require a large group of people to publish it and to keep publishing it.  It won't require a building that one must walk into in order to get a copy.  It simply exists in electronic format for anyone and everyone who has a computer device who wants to read it.  The Internet has brought publishing to the masses, and now anybody can publish anything, and no editor is required!

    That's right, there is no editor or publishing group to keep us in check.  We can publish anything we want about anybody we want, including libelous words without having to even think twice before pressing send.  It's my belief that the Internet hasn't really made us any more cruel and horrible people toward each other, it's simply revealed our hearts for what they are . . . black and stony.   And so the other edge of that double-edged sword, the internet, it cuts like a knife and many needless wounds are made.  Believers routinely cut each other down.  And they try and gain followings online by exposing those they have determined are in error.  But this exposing of other people sometimes exposes the hearts of the exposer.

    Men have forgotten that on the other end of the attack is another man.  No matter how famous, powerful, wrong, and truly vile this person may be, he's still another living and breathing human being.  And this person could be another blood-bought sinner just like us.  We must ask ourselves in our attacks on other people, what is the purpose of this attack?  Is this my flesh speaking, or am I truly struggling to use my words to edify someone else?   Do I just want others to share in my outrage, or do I want others to be bulit up in the truth?   The sciptures are clear that others will know us by whether or not we love one another (John 13:34-35), not by "winning" an internet debate.

    Think about this the next time you sit down to "roast" another human being with your public social media post and ask yourself these questions...

  1. "Why am I doing this?"
  2. "Is this really necessary?"  
  3. "What good can come from this?"  
  4. "Am I hurting anyone needlessly?"  
  5. "Is there a better way to get my point across?"  

    Instead of attacking the man, sometimes it's better to just attack a concept or just preach the truth.  These days, if I sense that someone really has it out for someone else, I simply ignore them.  It wouldn't matter how right this person is, I simply don't want to hear about who said what or who preached such and such.  The only thing I want to hear is Christ and Him crucified.  

Comments

0 / 2000 characters
Comments are moderated before appearing.

Be the first to comment!

Joshua

Joshua

Shall we play a game? Ask me about articles, sermons, or theology from our library. I can also help you navigate the site.